clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Off-Day Open Thread: Where Do The Orlando Magic Stand?


The battle deciding who's playing third fiddle to the Boston Celtics and Cleveland Cavaliers is still being fought. 

AP Photo/Reinhold Matay

Merry Christmas Eve everyone!

With the Magic's recent flurry of home wins against West heavyweights (San Antonio Spurs, Los Angeles Lakers) this past week, it's worth checking out (in case anyone here has missed it) where the power rankings place Orlando and determine whether the critics are right or wrong. 


ESPN (Marc Stein): 4th

Wanted to bump the Magic up to No. 3 after quality wins (at last) over the Blazers, Spurs and Lakers. If the Lakers weren't 10-3 against the rest of the top 15 -- closer than anyone to Boston's 9-1 -- we would have.


ESPN (John Hollinger): 4th

Is it too outlandish to say the top three teams in basketball might all be in the same conference? 


The Magic are now within less than 0.1 of the Lakers in the current Power Rankings, and finish only one win behind L.A. in today's Playoff Odds , so certainly they have a case.


Sports Illustrated (Chris Mannix): 4th

Another week, another whooping of the Western Conference. With victories against Golden State, San Antonio and the Lakers, Orlando improved to 11-4 against the West. That's a far cry from 2007-2008, when the Magic were only 14-16 in interconference games.


Yahoo! Sports (Ball Don't Lie): 3rd 

You could argue it away, say that this sort of production is the logical extension of what we saw in 2006-07, and that last year was a fluke. Hardly matters. Jameer Nelson (about 17 points and five assists) is killing it in only 32 minutes a night. Maybe Dick Vitale was right. I'd make a bad follow-up joke ("Nah..."), but it does burn a bit.



It's obvious the Magic are, at minimum, the 4th-best team in the NBA, but now with a victory over the Lakers .. the question is, can Orlando be regarded as the 3rd-best team in the NBA? It's certainly a topic worth debating. 


What are everyone's thoughts? Should the Magic be considered a top three team following a head-to-head victory over the Lake Show? If not, would a victory over the New Orleans Hornets tomorrow afternoon make a difference? Or .. does it matter where Orlando currently stands amongst the elite teams (the Spurs theory)?